Small wind / Buyer questions
Procurement and engineering handover
Can a wind supplier remove one unusual result and report only the passing average?
The short answer
Only when the approved procedure and documented evidence justify the exclusion and the decision rule permits the resulting calculation. A surprising observation can be a data error, a test fault or a genuine result. Deleting it solely because it makes an average fail loses evidence and may change the release decision.
Preserve the original reading and its context
Ask for the full sequence, test article identity, instrument, method and operating state when the value occurred. NIST’s statistics handbook treats unusual observations as candidates for investigation and notes they should not simply be deleted. A possible recording mistake and a real intermittent fault call for different treatment. Retain the raw result and the reason it was questioned.
Apply the approved measurement and decision rule
Determine whether the original requirement uses individual values, a maximum, a mean or another statistic. Even an approved retest does not make those criteria interchangeable. If an identifiable issue invalidated a measurement, document how it was found and what the approved procedure says to do next. If the cause remains unresolved, report the result and any alternative calculation separately. A passing average cannot silently replace an individual limit that applies to each item or state.
Keep the disposition traceable for the buyer
Request the original and revised calculations, the excluded observation, the stated reason and the authority responsible for accepting the change. If a repeat was performed, identify which conditions matched and what still differs. The release record should allow the buyer to reproduce the result and see whether the decision depends on the exclusion. A concise supplier summary can point to that evidence without removing the unresolved measurement from the record.
Sources
Examples are illustrative. Confirm product-specific performance, compatibility and supply scope in the applicable documents.