Can a wind supplier carry a Cpk value forward after the drawing tolerance changes?

Small wind / Buyer questions

Procurement and engineering handover

Can a wind supplier carry a Cpk value forward after the drawing tolerance changes?

The short answer

Ask the supplier to evaluate process capability against the current specification limits. Cpk, the process capability index that accounts for how close the process mean is to the nearer limit, uses the limits in its calculation. A changed tolerance can change the index even if the production measurements and process itself are unchanged.

Identify the calculation behind the reported number

Obtain the drawing characteristic, old and new limits, dataset date range, units and the method used to estimate process spread. Ask whether the study represents a stable process and a consistent measurement method. A reported index with only a part number and a date gives the reviewer too little information to compare the result with the revised drawing.

The NIST engineering statistics handbook defines Cpk using the process mean and spread and the distance to each specification limit. Its standard example assumes normal data. Ask for the agreed method if the data or study conditions require a different treatment.

Assess whether the old measurements can be reused

For a hypothetical mounting dimension, suppose the old tolerance was 19.8 to 20.2 mm and the current tolerance is 19.9 to 20.1 mm. If the process is centered at 20.0 mm with the same estimated spread, the distance to the nearer limit is halved, so the resulting Cpk is also halved under that calculation.

If the revised drawing also changes the datum or the supplier adjusts the process, confirm that the original readings still describe the same characteristic and production conditions before recalculating.

Keep the capability decision with the revised specification

Record the accepted drawing revision, the dataset and the supplier calculation. Mark any result that still applies only to the older limits. If the measurements or stability evidence are insufficient, agree a new study and when it is due. Apply the purchase order’s agreed inspection or release criteria to actual units separately.

Sources

Examples are illustrative. Confirm product-specific performance, compatibility and supply scope in the applicable documents.