What should a wind supplier provide when an acceptance requirement is verified by analysis?

Small wind / Buyer questions

Procurement and engineering handover

What should a wind supplier provide when an acceptance requirement is verified by analysis?

The short answer

Where the approved verification plan allows analysis, ask for the result and enough of its basis for the responsible engineer to assess applicability. A calculation summary can identify the conclusion. The evidence package also needs to identify the configuration, inputs, assumptions and load or operating cases on which that conclusion depends.

Confirm the method for the named requirement

Identify the requirement and its approved revision, the decision criterion and the scope that analysis is intended to cover. For example, a calculation may assess the deflection of a mounting support under agreed load cases, while installation checks verify that the actual support and attachments match the model. Keep both evidence routes tied to their respective requirements.

NASA’s systems engineering handbook lists analysis separately from testing, inspection and demonstration and describes retaining verification assumptions, versions and results. The project’s agreed verification plan determines the acceptable method for the equipment at hand.

Test the applicability of the assumptions

Ask for the drawing or model revision, input data and sources, supports, loads, method or software version and the result compared with the criterion. Preserve the range of cases covered and any sensitivity relevant to the decision. In the support example, moving an attachment may change the modeled load path even when the load magnitude stays the same.

If the project cannot confirm a site input, identify it as unresolved and record who will verify it.

Retain the evidence needed to review the conclusion

Agree which calculation sheets, model outputs or controlled technical summaries will be supplied and what review access is available for supporting material. Record the responsible reviewer, applicable configuration and any conditions or complementary checks. If an input or design revision changes, ask the reviewer to decide whether the original analysis still covers it or whether a revision or another approved verification method is needed.

Sources

Examples are illustrative. Confirm product-specific performance, compatibility and supply scope in the applicable documents.