Can two wind vibration reports compare first order if they use different shafts as the speed reference?

Small wind / Buyer questions

Mechanical and structural acceptance

Can two wind vibration reports compare first order if they use different shafts as the speed reference?

The short answer

First order means one cycle per revolution of the shaft used as the reference. It can represent different frequencies in reports referenced to different shafts. Confirm what speed each analyst used and compare both results on one documented reference before accepting the comparison.

Identify the physical shaft behind the speed channel

Ask for the sensor location, the shaft or rotating feature it observes, and the reference shaft selected in processing. A channel named rotor speed might represent measured generator speed converted by software. A tachometer can also generate several pulses per revolution, so the report should identify how its pulse rate became shaft speed.

Keep the machine configuration and recorded speed history with the processed plot. They let a reviewer see whether the conversion was applied to the correct operating interval.

Use one frequency and speed basis

In a hypothetical geared train, a rotor at 120 rpm has a once-per-revolution frequency of 2 Hz. A generator shaft at 360 rpm has a corresponding frequency of 6 Hz. A 6 Hz feature is first order on the generator reference and third order on the rotor reference in that example.

Dewesoft documents conversion between shaft references when a speed sensor is located on another component. A ratio entry needs a defined numerator and denominator. This example does not describe a MARSTON drivetrain.

Make the comparison reproducible

Request the original speed trace, the physical shaft reference, the ratio definition and the matching vibration intervals. Have the analyst state how both reports were placed on a common order or frequency axis. If the shaft reference cannot be established, record the comparison as unresolved and keep each report with its own limitations.

Sources

Examples are illustrative. Confirm product-specific performance, compatibility and supply scope in the applicable documents.