Can a separate average RPM log validate vibration order phase during a wind speed change?

Small wind / Buyer questions

Condition monitoring and commissioning

Can a separate average RPM log validate vibration order phase during a wind speed change?

The short answer

An average RPM record alone does not establish the angular reference needed to validate a vibration order’s phase through a speed change. The reviewer needs the speed or angle history and its relationship to the vibration samples. Dewesoft’s order-analysis example combines synchronized data with angle measurement and order amplitude and phase extraction. Check how the actual analysis obtains that reference.

Identify the information retained from rotation

Record the physical shaft, reference event, sensor or approved estimation method, and the original speed or angle channel. Ask whether the available values are pulse timing, instantaneous estimates or averages over longer intervals. A correct shaft name and ratio do not determine when each angular observation corresponds to a vibration sample. Preserve the acquisition and processing time bases and any documented alignment between them.

Evaluate the variable-speed case

In a hypothetical wind test, vibration is recorded continuously while a separate controller exports average RPM values. The shaft accelerates within each reporting interval. Several angular histories can share the same average speed, so those values alone cannot reconstruct the reference phase throughout the interval. Matching the clocks’ displayed date and time does not supply the rotation information lost in averaging.

Retain the basis of the reported order phase

Ask the analyst for the approved reference method, its synchronization evidence, relevant resampling settings and the original intervals behind the phase plot. Where speed is estimated from vibration, retain the method’s validation for the required operating case. Any unsupported phase interval should remain identified in the report. This lets commissioning judge the specific order-phase requirement and gives the buyer a defined data-acquisition capability to request. It also keeps an otherwise useful operating-speed log attached to the limited information it actually contains.

Sources

Examples are illustrative. Confirm product-specific performance, compatibility and supply scope in the applicable documents.