Small wind / Buyer questions
Cabinet protection and component selection
Can a higher SPD Imax replace the specified Iimp duty in a wind-cabinet order?
The short answer
The specified impulse-current duty needs matching declared evidence. Schneider Electric’s Electrical Installation Guide describes Iimp using a 10/350 µs current waveform and Imax using an 8/20 µs waveform. Their peak-current numbers carry different test-wave conditions. Ask the supplier to identify the proposed device’s declared rating for the duty required by the accepted project specification.
Preserve the specified current quantity
Read the SPD schedule with the project’s approved surge-protection design. Record the required device type, current quantity, waveform and the pole or protection mode to which the rating applies. Ask the supplier to show the corresponding entry in the exact proposed part’s manufacturer documentation. Keep the voltage and system-arrangement requirements attached to the substitution review so its scope remains clear to procurement.
Assess the proposed higher-number substitute
In a hypothetical order, the accepted schedule requires 12.5 kA Iimp at 10/350 µs. An alternative quotation highlights 50 kA Imax at 8/20 µs. The reviewer requests the alternative’s declared Iimp and applicable Type 1 evidence before deciding whether it meets the schedule. A combined Type 1+2 device may provide several declared duties, each of which needs its own applicable supporting entry.
Release the order against documented duties
Retain the exact part reference, manufacturer rating table and supplier’s completed comparison with the approved requirement. Have the responsible designer disposition any missing declaration or changed protection mode. Include the accepted documentation in the commissioning and spares records. Future purchasers should be able to identify the required waveform and rating basis directly from that record and refer a proposed substitute for review against the same approved project duty.
Sources
Examples are illustrative. Confirm product-specific performance, compatibility and supply scope in the applicable documents.