Can two wind roses be compared if their compass sectors have different boundaries?

Small wind / Buyer questions

Site measurement and data handoff

Can two wind roses be compared if their compass sectors have different boundaries?

The short answer

Only after checking what angles each spoke represents. A spoke labelled north may represent angles on both sides of north, while a numerical sector label may mark its starting edge. When the boundaries differ, the same wind observations can populate different sectors. Comparing the spoke percentages without aligning their definitions can make a stable wind pattern appear to move.

Get the sector table behind each chart

Ask for the number of sectors, centre or edge convention and the exact range of angles assigned to each label. Include the treatment of angles on boundaries and how the north sector wraps from 360 degrees back to zero. Check that both charts use the same incoming-direction convention and north reference. The NOAA wind rose guide describes the spokes as frequencies and allows different numbers of compass points.

Re-bin the angles when the source permits it

For example, a hypothetical north sector centred at 0 degrees with width 30 degrees contains a 350-degree observation. A bin that begins at 0 degrees and ends before 30 degrees does not. If the archived observations retain their directions, count them on the same new sector edges. If only published totals remain, a count from an old sector that crosses a new boundary cannot be split exactly without further information.

Compare records with an explicit denominator

Keep the valid periods, calm treatment and observation weights consistent. A chart of frequency by sector and one weighted by energy answer different questions even when their edges align. Ask the site assessor for comparable sector counts and the coverage after re-binning before using the difference to move a proposed turbine or alter an obstacle review. If exact re-binning is impossible, report the comparison at a defensible shared resolution or leave the angular difference unresolved.

Sources

Examples are illustrative. Confirm product-specific performance, compatibility and supply scope in the applicable documents.