Does a two-beam horizontal lidar reconstruction establish that vertical wind was negligible?

Small wind / Buyer questions

Lidar geometry and wind reconstruction

Does a two-beam horizontal lidar reconstruction establish that vertical wind was negligible?

The short answer

The reconstruction needs an explicit vertical-flow assumption. Two LOS observations do not independently determine an arbitrary three-component wind vector. The DNV–Vaisala guide shows that a nonzero vertical velocity contributes to an elevated beam’s radial observation. A horizontal reconstruction that neglects that term needs an applicability assessment for the actual geometry and flow.

Identify the omitted contribution

Record both beam elevations and the reconstruction’s treatment of vertical velocity. Ask which evidence supports neglecting its contribution for the requested statistic and measurement locations. A mathematically available horizontal solution does not independently verify the assumption used to obtain it. Keep this question separate from uncertainty magnification caused by a poor horizontal crossing angle.

Review a hypothetical changed observation region

A supplier applies an existing horizontal retrieval to another observation region with different elevation geometry and possible vertical motion. The buyer requests the applicable sensitivity assessment before accepting the series unchanged. The Perdigão study found a small vertical-assumption effect for its assessed observations, while discussing why larger elevations and different vertical flow could change that result.

Retain the supported flow boundary

Keep geometry, relevant flow evidence and the specialist’s disposition with the reconstruction record. Identify conditions not covered by that assessment and the additional information required. Do not turn a study-specific finding into a universal zero-vertical-wind declaration or infer a measured vertical component from a reconstruction that assumed it away. No MARSTON measurement capability or site correction follows from the generic equations.

Sources

Examples are illustrative. Confirm product-specific performance, compatibility and supply scope in the applicable documents.