Why can a flange pass average roughness and still need a scratch review?

Small wind / Buyer questions

Mechanical inspection and field service

Why can a flange pass average roughness and still need a scratch review?

The short answer

An average roughness reading represents the measured trace. A local defect can cross the actual gasket contact band even when the surrounding finish is acceptable. Garlock's gasket guidance describes limits on flange imperfections and the importance of the specified surface finish. For a visible scratch, ask where it goes, what part of the gasket contact it crosses and how the applicable joint requirement treats it.

Map the defect to the seal boundary

Record the flange identifier, gasket type, contact width and position of the mark. Describe whether the mark runs across or along the sealing band and whether it reaches either side. In a hypothetical inspection a radial scratch lies between the locations used for routine roughness checks. The passing routine measurements and the local inspection can both be accurate because they cover different areas.

Read the repair and finish criteria together

Request the equipment or gasket supplier's acceptable surface condition and the approved inspection method. Keep local depth, extent and any other relevant observations with the overall finish record. A drawing of intended serrations is not evidence that a separate scratch is acceptable. Similarly, a visual mark alone may be insufficient to establish its depth or whether it can be evaluated within the applicable procedure.

Confirm the accepted joint configuration

Have the responsible reviewer disposition any defect and retain evidence of the finished surface if repair is approved. Use the specified gasket and joint checks for the actual assembly. Keep the flange face result separate from tower flange flatness or general structural alignment records, which have different acceptance purposes. This enables a later buyer or technician to see which sealing surface and local condition were actually assessed.

Sources

Examples are illustrative. Confirm product-specific performance, compatibility and supply scope in the applicable documents.